Faculty

Hiring Godly, qualified teachers and administrators is crucial to fulfilling our mission as a school.  Our staff must exemplify the highest Christian character as they reflect Christ’s love and encourage each child’s own obedient response to God.  Our staff meets the educational requirements as established by the State of Ohio and are licensed to teach in their area.
Mrs. Susan Gifford, Academy President
Mrs. Gifford has been serving as the Administrator for the school since its opening in the 2005-2006 school year. She brings more than 20 years of business experience to her position. Mrs. Gifford holds a Bachelor’s Degree from Bowling Green State University, a Master’s from Cleveland State University and has completed coursework in Early Childhood Education at Lakeland Community College. Mrs. Gifford, her husband Russ, and daughter Emily live in Orwell.
Mr. Mark Smith, Troy Campus Administrator
Mr. Smith earned his Bachelor of Arts in Pastoral Studies from Cedarville University after starting his college career as a Math Major. He also holds a Master of Divinity from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. Mr. Smith resides in Burton with his wife Melissa and his children Micah, Gabriel, Eleana and Andrew. Mr. Smith joined Agape for the 2018-2019 school year.
Mrs. Bridget Cole, Three/Four & Four/Five Preschool Teacher
Mrs. Cole earned her Bachelor of Arts in Elementary Education from Lake Erie College and taught for three years at Painesville Christian Academy. Mrs. Cole joined Agape’s teaching team for the 2018-2019 school year and resides in Chardon with her husband and six children.
Mrs. Elizabeth Miller, Four/Five Preschool Teacher
Mrs. Miller holds a Bachelor of Arts in Early Childhood Education at Mount Union College and holds a Preschool through Third Grade teaching license with a Reading Endorsement for Preschool through Twelfth. She joined Agape’s teaching team for the 2014-2015 school year bringing experience as a Kindergarten teacher and Reading Intervention Tutor. Mrs. Miller resides in Burton with her husband Caleb, sons Oliver and Sawyer and daughter Lucy.
 
Mrs. Susan Petrick, Kindergarten Teacher
s.petrick@agapeca.com

Mrs. Petrick holds a Bachelor of Science in Education from Bowling Green State University with a teaching license for Kindergarten through Eighth Grade.  She has also served as a Three/Four Preschool Teacher and Tutor at Agape. Mrs. Petrick, her husband Shawn and daughters Lauren, Rachel and Lindsey reside in Middlefield.  Mrs. Petrick joined Agape for the 2012-2013 school year.
 
Mrs. Amy Taddeo, Kindergarten Teacher
a.taddeo@agapeca.com

Mrs. Taddeo holds a Bachelor of Arts in Elementary Education from Lake Erie College with a teaching license for First through Eighth Grade with a concentration in reading.  Mrs. Taddeo, her husband Al and daughters Isabella and Maddy reside in Chardon.  Mrs. Taddeo joined Agape for the 2015-2016 school year.

Mrs. Michelle Tiber, First Grade Teacher
m.tiber@agapeca.com

Mrs. Tiber earned her Bachelor’s Degree in Early Childhood Education from Malone University with a teaching license for Preschool through Third Grade. After graduating from Malone, she spent time on the mission field teaching English in Honduras and has also served as a teacher in Quito Ecuador in a First and Sixth Grade Classroom. Mrs. Tiber joined Agape for the 2016-2017 school year.  She resides in Burton with her husband Adam.

Miss Kalyn Ward, First Grade Teacher
k.ward@agapeca.com

Miss Ward holds a Bachelor of Arts in Education from the University of Mount Union with a major in Early Childhood Education and minors in Intervention Specialist and Psychology. Her teaching license is in Early Childhood Education.  Miss Ward resides in Chardon and joined Agape for the 2015-2016 school year.
Mrs. Havilah Southern, Second Grade Teacher
Mrs. Southern has been with Agape since our first school year in 2005-2006. She holds a Bachelor’s Degree in Early Childhood Education from Kent State University. Prior to joining Agape, she was a teacher at Head Start. Mrs. Southern, her husband Mike, and sons Elijah, Abram, Aaron and Caleb reside in Hiram.
Miss Faith Menefee, Third Grade Teacher
Miss Menefee holds a Bachelor of Science in Elementary Education from Grove City with a minor in Studio Arts. Her teaching license is in PreKindergarten thru Fourth Grade with field experience in several grades.  Miss Menefee joined Agape for the 2019-2020 school year.
Mr. Larry Domokos, Fourth Grade Teacher
Mr. Domokos holds a Bachelor of Science in Elementary Education from Faith Baptist Bible College and a Master of Arts in Elementary Administration and Supervision from Bob Jones University. He brings 36 years of Christian school teaching experience from Northfield Baptist Christian School. Mr. Domokos resides in Middlefield. He joined Agape for the 2016-2017 school year. 
Mrs. April Westover, Fourth Grade Teacher
Mrs. Westover earned her degree in Early Childhood Education from Youngstown State University. She completed student teaching in Third Grade in the Warren City Public Schools and has also served as a Tutor at Cardinal Elementary School and taught Preschool for Geauga Head Start. Mrs. Westover resides in West Farmington with her husband Brian and her two sons. Mrs. Westover joined Agape for the 2018-2019 school year.
 Miss Kristie Mencarini, Fifth Grade Teacher 
k.mencarini@agapeca.com
Miss Mencarini earned her Bachelor of Arts in Physical Education with a Minor in Bible and Health from Cedarville University and her Masters from Liberty University. She spent three years teaching in China and served in a camp and a Christian school in South Africa. For 12 years she served in a variety of teaching and coaching roles at Northfield Baptist Christian School. Miss Mencarini resides in Bedford and joined Agape for the 2017-2018 serving as Agape’s Elementary Phys Ed Teacher.
Mr. Mike Southern, Fifth Grade Teacher 
m.southern@agapeca.com
Mr. Southern earned a Bachelor’s of Science in Middle Childhood Education from Kent State University and previously served at Agape as a full-time Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Grade teacher as well as an Elementary and High School Physical Education Instructor. Mr. Southern has been a part of Agape’s teaching team on and off since 2005, the year the school opened. He currently serves as Pastor at Christ Covenant Church in Middlefield. Mr. Southern is husband to Mrs. Southern, Agape’s Second Grade Teacher. They reside in Hiram with their boys Elijah, Abram, Aaron and Caleb.
Mrs. Jeni Najjar, Sixth Grade Teacher
Mrs. Najjar holds a Bachelor of Science in Education from Kent State University after attending The Moody Bible Institute for two years. She earned her teaching certification for Kindergarten through Eighth Grade and taught Third Grade and Fourth Grade at Berkshire Elementary before staying home to raise her family. Mrs. Najjar resides in Huntsburg with her husband Rick and children Callie, Nathaniel and Cooper.  She joined Agape for the 2016-2017 school year.
Mrs. Mary Carr, Middle/High School Teacher 
m.carr@agapeca.com

Mrs. Carr holds a Bachelor of Arts in Secondary Education and a Masters of Education in Reading and Literacy with a Reading Endorsement from Baldwin Wallace College. She holds a Teaching License in History Grades 7 thru 12. Mrs. Carr and her husband Mike reside in Sagamore Hills. She joined Agape for the 2011-2012 school year.

Mrs. Lorna Chavez,

Middle School Teacher and Spanish Teacher
Mrs. Chavez attended Grove City College where she earned a Bachelor of Arts in Elementary Education with a Minor in Spanish. She holds a Grade 1 thru 8 teaching license, and Association of Christian Schools International Educator’s Certificate and a State of Ohio Non-tax Supported School Certificate. Mrs. Chavez brings 25 years of teaching experience to Agape all of which was at Warren Christian School where she taught Middle School Language Arts, Social Studies and Spanish, High School Spanish and Bible. Mrs. Chavez and her family reside in Southington. Mrs. Chavez has been with Agape since the 2010-2011 school year.

Mr. Dan Itschner, Middle/High School Guidance Counselor d.itschner@agapeca.comMr. Itschner holds a Bachelor of Science in Elementary Education and a Master of Administration and Counseling from Kent State University. He brings over 30 years of educational experience with the Berkshire School District where he served as a teacher, principal and counselor. He also served at Geauga Christian School prior to his college graduation. Mr. Itschner and his wife Mim reside in Burton.  Mr. Itschner has been with Agape since the 2012-2013 school year.
 
Miss Esther Kershaw,
High School English & Speech Teacher
Miss Kershaw earned her Bachelor of Arts in English and Secondary
Education with a minor in English as a Second Language from Calvin College in Michigan. She holds her teaching certification in English and ESL for Sixth through Twelfth Grade. She has field experience in High School English and also taught ESL in a refugee education center and served as a peer coach and tutor at Calvin College.  Miss Kershaw resides in Chesterland and joined Agape for the 2019-2020 school year.
 
Miss Hannah Lain,
High School Math Teacher
Miss Lain earned her Bachelor of Science with a double major in Mathematics Education and Pure Math from Trevecca Nazarene University in Tennessee. She holds a license for Sixth through Twelfth Grade Math and has field experience with Middle and High School students as a teacher, tutor and Camp Counselor.  Miss Lain resides in Kent and joined Agape for the 2019-2020 school year.
Miss Brenna Rupe,
High School  Science Teacher
Miss Rupe earned her Bachelor of Science in Middle Level Science and Social Studies Education from Grove City College. Miss Rupe has served at summer camps working with elementary through high school age children. She was a member of the Varsity Cross Country and Track and Field teams at Grove City College and also participated in Fellowship of Christian Educators. Miss Rupe resides in Cortland and joined Agape for the 2020-2021 school year.
Mr. Kevin Wilmot,
Middle/High School Bible Teacher
Mr. Wilmot is a graduate of the Moody Bible Institute. He holds a Bachelors in Education with a Major in Bible.  He also earned a Bachelors in Physics and a Bachelors in Religious Studies from Cleveland State University. He joined Agape as a Student Teacher in the Fall of 2014 before graduating and now teaches Bible. He resides in Claridon with his wife Kelly and their four children.